SAMDCOT warns of impact on patient care, medical education as gynaecology unit proposed to shift from Kamla Nehru Hospital to IGMC Shimla
The State Association of Medical and Dental College Teachers (SAMDCOT) has strongly opposed the Himachal Pradesh government’s decision to bifurcate the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology (OBG) by shifting the gynaecology unit from Kamla Nehru Hospital to Indira Gandhi Medical College.
Decision Called Illogical and Against Medical Norms
In an official statement, the association termed the move “illogical, unprecedented, and against established medical and academic principles.” SAMDCOT emphasized that the OBG department traditionally functions as a single, integrated unit across the world, especially in teaching institutions where coordinated care and academic training are critical.
Concerns Over Patient Care and Treatment Quality
The association warned that separating gynaecology from obstetrics could severely compromise patient outcomes. According to them, effective OBG care depends on seamless coordination between the two specialities. Fragmentation, they said, may lead to delays, inefficiencies, and a decline in treatment standards.
Impact on Medical Education and Training
SAMDCOT also raised concerns about the academic fallout of the decision. The bifurcation is expected to disrupt undergraduate and postgraduate training programmes, which rely on a structured and integrated approach to OBG education.
Robotic Surgery Justification Questioned
The Himachal Pradesh government has cited the introduction of robotic surgery at IGMC as a key reason for the shift. However, the association dismissed this argument, stating that robotic procedures are required in only a small percentage of cases and are currently available for gynaecology patients only three days a week.
Infrastructure at Kamla Nehru Hospital Highlighted
The association pointed out that Kamla Nehru Hospital already has adequate infrastructure and planned expansions, including an IVF centre, a fetal medicine unit, and an oncology centre. These projects, they warned, could face indefinite delays if the bifurcation proceeds.
Political Opposition Mounts
The move has also sparked political controversy. Leaders from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) have opposed the proposed shift, expressing concerns that it could negatively impact maternal healthcare services and patient safety in the region.
Government’s Stand
The Chief Minister has defended the decision, stating that shifting the gynaecology department to Indira Gandhi Medical College would enhance access to advanced facilities, including robotic surgery.
